Your Profit Target Is the Only MAO Input You Choose
The full-cost version of Maximum Allowable Offer looks like this: MAO = ARV - rehab - buying costs - holding costs - selling costs - target profit. Every dollar you subtract from the After Repair Value is a dollar you can't pay the seller. Most investors spend their energy arguing about comps and contractor bids. But one line in that formula works differently from the rest.
Want to skip the spreadsheet? FlipSmrt pulls comps, estimates ARV and rehab, and runs the deal math from just an address. Your first 3 analyses are free.
Look at where each input comes from. ARV comes from recent sold comps near the property, and rehab comes from the house's condition and local labor pricing. Buying costs (title, escrow, inspections) and selling costs (agent commissions, transfer taxes, concessions) are set by your market. Holding costs depend on your loan rate, taxes, insurance, and utilities over the months you own it. You can estimate these well or badly, but you don't get to pick them.
Target profit is the exception. It's a policy decision, and it's the only number in the formula you set on purpose. Investors usually set it one of three ways:
- Flat dollar minimum: "I don't flip for less than $30,000," regardless of price point.
- Percent of ARV: profit equals a fixed share of the resale price, often 10% to 20%.
- Percent return on total cost: profit equals a set return on everything you put in (purchase, rehab, and transaction and carrying costs), so it grows as the project gets bigger.
The 70% rule hides a profit target inside it. With MAO = (ARV x 0.70) - repairs, a $250,000 ARV and $40,000 rehab gives $175,000 - $40,000 = $135,000. That leftover 30% of ARV, or $75,000, has to cover buying, holding, selling, and profit together. If those costs run about $30,000, the rule quietly assumes a $45,000 profit, which is 18% of ARV. You never chose that number, and in a market with higher costs or thinner margins it may be the wrong one. Writing profit as its own line makes that decision visible, and the next two sections show how much the choice moves your offer.
Worked Example: A $180K ARV Starter Flip Under Three Profit Rules
Start with a typical starter flip: a 3-bed ranch with comps supporting an ARV of $180,000. The rehab budget is $35,000, holding costs (loan interest, taxes, insurance, utilities) run $9,000, and selling costs at 8% come to $14,400. Buying costs are 2% of whatever you pay, so the purchase price (P) shows up twice. Your fixed costs total $58,400 before profit, and the equation is ARV = 1.02P + $58,400 + profit.
Now plug in three different profit rules and solve for P:
- Flat $30,000: 1.02P = $180,000 - $58,400 - $30,000 = $91,600, so P = $91,600 / 1.02, or about $89,800.
- 15% of ARV ($27,000): 1.02P = $180,000 - $58,400 - $27,000 = $94,600, so P is about $92,700.
- 20% return on total cost: total cost = $180,000 / 1.2 = $150,000, so profit is $30,000. That gives the same 1.02P = $91,600 and a MAO of about $89,800.
For a gut check, the 70% rule gives ($180,000 x 0.70) - $35,000 = $91,000. All four answers land between $89,800 and $92,700, a spread of under $3,000. On a deal this size, that gap is smaller than one bad bid from a roofer.
The methods agree because the numbers happen to line up at this price point. At $180K, 15% of ARV ($27,000) is close to $30,000, and 20% on a $150,000 cost basis is exactly $30,000. The 70% rule's $54,000 cushion (30% of ARV) covers about $25,200 in buying, holding, and selling costs and leaves roughly $28,800 of profit, which is the same ballpark again.
The takeaway is that on low-priced flips, your choice of profit rule barely moves the offer. Pick whichever you can defend and spend your energy on the inputs that actually swing this deal: the ARV comps and the rehab budget. A $10,000 rehab miss here costs you three times more than switching profit rules ever would.
Worked Example: A $450K ARV Flip Where the Rules Split by $37K
Now scale up. Picture a four-bedroom colonial with an ARV of $450,000, a $70,000 rehab, $20,000 in holding costs, selling costs of 8% ($36,000), and buying costs of 2% of the purchase price. Because buying costs depend on the price you pay, each MAO below solves for that price: everything left after rehab, holding, selling, and profit, divided by 1.02.
- Flat $30K profit: $450,000 - $70,000 - $20,000 - $36,000 - $30,000 = $294,000. Divided by 1.02, that is an MAO of about $288,200.
- 15% of ARV ($67,500): $450,000 - $126,000 - $67,500 = $256,500. Divided by 1.02, that is about $251,500.
- 20% on total cost: Total cost must equal $450,000 / 1.20 = $375,000, so profit is $75,000. Then $375,000 - $126,000 = $249,000, and $249,000 / 1.02 is about $244,100.
For comparison, the 70% rule gives ($450,000 x 0.70) - $70,000 = $245,000. The 15% and 20% rules land close to that benchmark. The flat $30K target sits about $37,000 above the 15% figure and about $44,000 above the cost-based one.
That gap exists because a flat dollar amount ignores how much is at stake. At an MAO of $288,200, your all-in cost is roughly $420,000, so a $30,000 profit is only about a 7% return on the money and risk you have tied up. One permit delay, one foundation surprise, or a 4% softer resale price erases it entirely. The same $30K that felt generous on a $180K starter flip is a thin cushion on a deal more than twice the size.
The fix is to run all three targets before you write an offer, not after. Done by hand, that means three spreadsheet passes and a circular buying-cost calculation. FlipSmrt returns an MAO from whatever target profit you set, so you can test a flat dollar figure, a percent of ARV, and a percent of cost in a few minutes. If those answers are $40K apart, you have found the deal where your profit rule matters most.
Run these numbers on a real deal in under 5 minutes
FlipSmrt turns an address into ARV, a rehab budget, and your Maximum Allowable Offer automatically.
Analyze a Property FreeAdjusting the Profit Line for Risk, Leverage, and Hold Time
Your profit target should move with the risk in the deal. Foundation work, a full roof and framing repair, or anything behind walls you haven't opened deserves a fatter margin, because those budgets tend to grow once the work starts. The same goes for thin comps (only two sales within half a mile, or none in the last six months), timelines past six months, and price bands where listings sit for 60+ days. In those cases, pushing from 15% of ARV to 18% or 20% gives you room for the surprises the deal is likely to throw at you.
The opposite case is a light cosmetic wholetail: paint, flooring, fixtures, and a quick relist in a fast-moving neighborhood. With less scope and a shorter hold, there is less that can go wrong, so running 10% to 12% can be reasonable. That thinner margin only works if your rehab number is tight and your comps are recent and close.
Leverage changes how a target feels. Say a flip costs $250,000 all in and nets $50,000 after loan interest and points. That is a 20% return on total cost. If a lender funded everything except your $50,000 down payment and reserves, you doubled your own cash. The same leverage raises your risk, though. A $25,000 overrun eats half your profit, and holding costs keep piling up every month the house sits unsold.
A simple rule keeps you honest: use the stricter of a dollar floor and a percentage target. Pick a floor, such as $30,000, and a percentage, such as 15% of ARV. Then run both and plug the larger number into your MAO.
- ARV $160,000: 15% is $24,000, so the $30,000 floor wins.
- ARV $260,000: 15% is $39,000, so the percentage wins.
- Same $260,000 deal with structural scope at 18%: target becomes $46,800.
The floor protects your time on cheap houses. The percentage scales your margin as the dollars at risk grow.
Profit-Target Mistakes That Quietly Inflate Your Offers
Using one flat number at every price point. A $30K target is 16.7% of a $180K ARV but only 6.7% of a $450K ARV, so the same rule makes you far more aggressive on bigger deals. One rehab surprise on the larger flip wipes out the entire margin. Fix: set a dollar floor and a percentage of ARV, then use whichever is greater.
Applying the percentage to the wrong base. Fifteen percent of a $200K purchase price is $30K, while 15% of a $300K ARV is $45K. Running the math off purchase price quietly hands $15K of your margin to the seller. It also creates a circular problem, because the purchase price is the number you are trying to solve for. Fix: anchor the percentage to ARV or total project cost, and write down which one you used.
Double-counting profit by stacking the 70% rule on a full-cost MAO. Take a $300K ARV with $40K rehab, $27K in buying, holding, and selling costs, and a $45K profit target. Done correctly, that full-cost MAO is $300K minus $112K, or $188K. Start from $210K (70% of ARV) instead and subtract the same items, and you land at $98K. This error deflates offers rather than inflating them. It still costs you, because you lose good deals and then start trimming other lines to compensate. Fix: use the 70% rule or a full-cost build, never both.
Forgetting that buying costs scale with price. Closing costs and loan points at 3% run $4,500 on a $150K purchase but $10,500 on a $350K one. Investors who plug in a fixed $5K inflate their MAO on every larger deal. Fix: calculate buying costs as a percentage of the offer price, not as a fixed dollar figure.
Lowering the target mid-negotiation to win the deal. The seller counters $12K above your MAO, so your $45K target becomes $33K "just this once." Nothing about the property changed. Only your discipline did. Fix: lock your walk-away number before the first offer, and only revise it if an input like ARV or rehab actually changes.
FAQ: Setting Target Profit in Your MAO
Is 15% of ARV a good default? It works as a starting point for mid-priced flips, but it breaks at both ends of the price range. On a $180K ARV, 15% is only $27,000, which a single surprise like a sewer line or foundation repair can erase. On a $450K ARV, 15% is $67,500, which may price you out of deals other buyers will take. A practical default is the greater of 15% of ARV or a fixed dollar floor like $30,000.
Should profit be measured before or after financing costs? After. Your target profit should be the money left once every loan cost is paid, so financing belongs in your buying and holding costs, not inside your profit line. On a $200,000 hard money loan at 12% for six months, interest alone is $12,000 ($200,000 x 0.12 x 0.5), and 2 points add another $4,000. If you count those dollars as profit, your real return is $16,000 lower than you planned.
What minimum dollar profit makes sense for a first flip? Set a floor of $25,000 to $30,000, even on a cheap house. First flips tend to run over on budget and timeline because you are still learning how to manage contractors and read a scope of work. If your target is $20,000 and you overrun rehab by $15,000, you just spent six months of work to earn $5,000. A higher floor means fewer deals qualify, but the ones that do can absorb your mistakes.
How do I set the target in FlipSmrt? Enter a US address or Zillow link, then enter your target profit. FlipSmrt calculates the MAO by starting with an ARV built from adjusted MLS sold comps within 0.5 miles, then subtracting line-item rehab priced for that county, buying, holding, and selling costs, and your profit number. You get a go or no-go verdict in plain English in under 5 minutes. Your first 3 analyses are free, so you can run the same deal at $30,000 and at 15% of ARV and compare the two offers directly.
Ready to analyze your next deal?
Get ARV, renovation estimates, and full deal math in under 5 minutes. Your first 3 analyses are free.
Start Free Analysis