what is a good cash on cash return
real estate investing
investment metrics
cash flow
property investment

What Is a Good Cash on Cash Return? Targets by Strategy

Hootan Nikbakht

Hootan Nikbakht

Real Estate Expert

November 11, 2025
15 min read
What Is a Good Cash on Cash Return? Targets by Strategy

A good cash on cash return for a leveraged long-term rental is commonly put at 8 to 12%, and many investors treat anything above 12% as strong. That range is a rule of thumb, not a statistic. What counts as "good" for you depends on your strategy, how you finance the deal and the market you buy in.

An investor buying all-cash in a high-appreciation city might happily accept 4 to 6%. A BRRRR investor who pulls most of their cash back out at refinance might expect far more. This guide shows how to calculate cash on cash return, why the target moves, and two worked examples (all-cash and leveraged) on the same property so you can see exactly how financing changes the answer.

What Cash on Cash Return Measures

Cash on cash return answers one question: for every dollar I put into this deal, how many cents come back to me in cash each year?

It ignores appreciation, loan paydown and tax benefits. It looks only at the cash you put in and the cash you get out in a given year. That makes it a clean way to measure how hard your own money is working right now.

It also lets you compare very different properties on equal terms. A lower-priced duplex can deliver a higher cash on cash return than a nicer single-family home, even if the house collects more total rent. The metric rewards efficiency, not size.

Quick takeaway: A higher percentage means your cash is generating more income relative to what you invested. It is a direct read on a property's year-one cash profitability.

What Is a Good Cash on Cash Return? It Depends on These Three Things

The 8 to 12% range is a useful screen, but it assumes a fairly typical deal: a long-term rental, bought with a conventional loan, in an average market. Change any of those and the target moves.

1. Your Strategy

The table below shows how investors commonly adjust their expectations by strategy. These are directional rules of thumb, not market averages.

StrategyHow the Target Usually ShiftsWhy
Long-term rental, leveragedThe common 8 to 12% screen appliesSteady income is the main reason to own it, so cash flow has to carry the deal.
Long-term rental, all-cashOften lowerMore cash is tied up and there is no loan risk, so the return on cash tends to land closer to the cap rate.
Small multifamily (2 to 4 units)Often higher than a single-family homeSeveral rent checks on one roof and one loan, but more management work.
Short-term rentalInvestors usually demand moreIncome is seasonal and the work is closer to running a hotel, so the return has to pay for that risk and effort.
BRRRRCan be very high after refinanceIf the refinance returns most of your cash, a modest cash flow divided by a small remaining investment produces a large percentage.
Appreciation playInvestors may accept low or near-zeroThe bet is on equity growth, not current income. That is a higher-risk approach.

For BRRRR deals, the key question is how much cash stays in the property after the refinance. Our guide to how much cash stays trapped in a BRRRR deal walks through that math.

2. Your Financing

Financing changes both halves of the formula. A smaller down payment shrinks your cash invested, which pushes the percentage up. But a bigger loan means bigger payments, which shrinks your cash flow. Whether leverage helps or hurts depends on whether the property earns more than the loan costs. The worked examples below show both effects.

3. Your Market

In markets where prices are high relative to rents, cash on cash returns tend to be thin, and investors there often rely more on appreciation. In markets where prices are lower relative to rents, cash flow is usually stronger but appreciation may be slower. Neither is better. Just make sure the target you use fits the market you are buying in.

A quick way to see where a market sits is to compare typical rents with typical prices for the property type you want. If a $300,000 house rents for $1,800 a month, a high cash on cash return will be hard to find with a loan at current rates. If a $150,000 house rents for $1,600, the same target may be very reachable. Set your expectations from that ratio, not from a number you read online.

How to Calculate Cash on Cash Return

The formula is simple:

Cash on Cash Return = Annual Pre-Tax Cash Flow / Total Cash Invested

Multiply by 100 to express it as a percentage.

Finding Your Annual Pre-Tax Cash Flow

Annual pre-tax cash flow is the money the property leaves in your pocket over a year, before income taxes. Here is how the main pieces fit together:

Screenshot from https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/1/1b/Cash_on_cash_return.png/800px-Cash_on_cash_return.png

  1. Start with gross rent: Total rent for 12 months at full occupancy.
  2. Subtract vacancy: No unit stays rented every month. The result is effective gross income.
  3. Subtract operating expenses: Taxes, insurance, management, maintenance and a CapEx reserve. What remains is net operating income (NOI).
  4. Subtract annual debt service: Your total mortgage payments (principal and interest) for the year. If you bought with cash, this is zero.

What is left is your annual pre-tax cash flow. If your expense list feels short, compare it with our guide to building a realistic expense stack from rent to NOI.

Defining Your Total Cash Invested

This is where many new investors go wrong. Total cash invested is not just the down payment. It is every dollar that left your bank account to buy the property and get it rented:

  • Down payment (or the full price, if you paid cash)
  • Closing costs: Appraisal, inspection, title insurance, loan fees and similar charges
  • Initial repairs: Anything you spent to make the property rent-ready

Key takeaway: Leaving closing costs or initial repairs out of total cash invested makes your return look better than it is. Count every out-of-pocket dollar.

Two Worked Examples: All-Cash vs. Leveraged

The clearest way to see why "good" depends on financing is to run the same property both ways. All numbers below are hypothetical.

Image

The Property

  • Purchase price: $140,000
  • Closing costs: $4,000
  • Initial repairs: $6,000
  • Rent: $1,750 a month, or $21,000 a year

First, the operating numbers. These are the same no matter how you pay for the house:

Line ItemAnnual AmountHow It Is Calculated
Gross rent$21,000$1,750 x 12
Vacancy (5%)-$1,050$21,000 x 0.05
Effective gross income$19,950$21,000 - $1,050
Property taxes-$2,100From the county bill
Insurance-$1,400Landlord policy quote
Management (8%)-$1,596$19,950 x 0.08
Maintenance (5%)-$1,050$21,000 x 0.05
CapEx reserve (5%)-$1,050$21,000 x 0.05
Net operating income (NOI)$12,754$19,950 - $7,196

The cap rate is NOI divided by price: $12,754 / $140,000 = 9.1%. Keep that number in mind.

Example 1: All-Cash Purchase

With no loan, there is no debt service, so cash flow equals NOI.

  • Total cash invested: $140,000 + $4,000 + $6,000 = $150,000
  • Annual pre-tax cash flow: $12,754 - $0 = $12,754 (about $1,063 a month)
  • Cash on cash return: $12,754 / $150,000 = 8.5%

Notice that the all-cash return (8.5%) is a little below the cap rate (9.1%). That is because closing costs and repairs add to your cash invested without adding to income.

Example 2: Leveraged Purchase (25% Down)

Now buy the same house with a 30-year loan at 7%.

  • Down payment: $140,000 x 0.25 = $35,000
  • Loan amount: $140,000 - $35,000 = $105,000
  • Monthly principal and interest: about $699, or $8,383 a year
  • Total cash invested: $35,000 + $4,000 + $6,000 = $45,000
  • Annual pre-tax cash flow: $12,754 - $8,383 = $4,371 (about $364 a month)
  • Cash on cash return: $4,371 / $45,000 = 9.7%

What the Two Examples Tell You

The leveraged deal earns a higher percentage (9.7% vs. 8.5%) but far less cash each month ($364 vs. $1,063). It also ties up $105,000 less of your money, which you could put into other deals.

Leverage helped here because the property earns more on its price (a 9.1% cap rate) than the loan costs each year. The annual payment of $8,383 is about 8.0% of the $105,000 loan balance. When the cap rate is above that number, borrowing raises your cash on cash return. When it is below, borrowing lowers it.

Run the same loan on a property with a 6% cap rate and the leveraged return falls below the all-cash return. Our mortgage constant test for rental deals explains this check in detail.

So is 9.7% "good"? For a leveraged long-term rental it sits inside the common 8 to 12% screen. Is 8.5% all-cash "good"? For many all-cash buyers, yes, because they carry no loan risk. The same property earns both numbers. The financing decides which one you get.

To run these numbers on your own deals, our real estate investment analysis spreadsheet guide lays out each row with the exact spreadsheet formulas.

Stress-Test the Leveraged Return

A 9.7% projection is only useful if it survives a bad year. Change one assumption at a time on Example 2 and see where the return lands:

ScenarioAnnual Cash FlowCash on Cash
Base case (5% vacancy, 7% rate)$4,3719.7%
Vacancy rises to 10%$3,4057.6%
Loan rate is 8% instead of 7%$3,5097.8%

The vacancy math: vacancy loss doubles to $2,100, effective gross income falls to $18,900, and management drops to $1,512 because it is charged on collected rent. Operating expenses total $7,112, so NOI is $11,788. Subtract the same $8,383 in debt service and $3,405 is left. The rate case keeps NOI at $12,754 but raises annual payments to about $9,245.

Either change pushes the deal below the 8% screen. That does not mean you should pass, but it tells you how little room there is. If a single bad assumption takes the return out of your target range, negotiate a lower price or keep a larger cash reserve.

How to Set Your Own Target

Rules of thumb are a starting point. A better approach is to build a target that fits your own money and goals.

  1. Start with your alternative. What would the same cash earn somewhere with less work and less risk? Your rental should beat that by enough to justify tenants, repairs and illiquidity.
  2. Add a premium for effort and risk. A self-managed older house in a market you do not know well deserves a higher target than a newer, professionally managed property close to home.
  3. Set a minimum monthly cash flow too. A high percentage on a tiny investment can still mean $50 a month. Many investors pair a percentage target with a minimum dollar amount per unit, so one repair does not erase the year.
  4. Decide how much appreciation you are counting on. If the answer is "most of the return," accept that the deal is a growth bet and size your reserves for it.

Write the target down before you start looking. It is much easier to walk away from a deal when the rule was set before you fell for the house.

Your Return Changes Over Time

Cash on cash return is usually quoted for year one, but it moves. Rents tend to rise while a fixed-rate payment stays flat, so cash flow can grow even if the cash you invested does not. Expenses rise too, especially taxes and insurance, so model both.

The denominator can change as well. If you refinance and pull cash out, your remaining cash invested drops and the percentage can jump, even though the property itself has not changed. When you compare deals, make sure you are comparing the same year and the same cash basis.

Other Factors That Move Your Return

Interest Rate and Loan Type

A small change in rate can swing cash flow noticeably. In Example 2, every dollar of extra annual payment comes straight out of the $4,371. An interest-only loan raises early cash flow (and the return) but builds no equity. A 30-year fixed loan costs more each month but gives you a predictable payment.

Property Type

Single-family homes are often easier to manage and to sell, but one vacancy means zero income. Small multifamily properties spread vacancy risk across several units, which tends to make cash flow steadier, though management and maintenance demands usually rise.

Market Demand

Steady job and population growth support rent levels and shorten vacancy. Before you offer, look at whether major employers are arriving or leaving and how long comparable rentals sit before they lease. Short vacancy periods directly protect the cash flow number in your formula.

Management Strategy

  • Self-management: Removes the management fee (often 8 to 12% of collected rent), which raises cash flow. You pay for it with your time: screening, rent collection and late-night repair calls.
  • Professional management: Makes the investment far more passive. The fee reduces cash flow, but a good manager may shorten vacancies and get better repair pricing.

Either way, run your numbers with a management line included. If the deal only works when you do all the work for free, that is worth knowing up front.

Looking Beyond a Single Metric

Cash on cash return measures your year-one cash yield. It does not tell you everything about a deal. Use it alongside a few other numbers.

Cap Rate

Cap rate is NOI divided by price. It measures the property's return as if you bought it with cash, which makes it ideal for comparing properties regardless of financing. NOI never subtracts mortgage payments. See what is a good cap rate for how investors judge that number.

Total ROI

Total return on investment adds the other ways a rental makes money: cash flow, appreciation and equity from loan paydown. It is usually measured over the whole hold, often at sale. A property with a modest cash on cash return can still produce a strong total return if it appreciates and you pay down the loan. Our guide on what is a good ROI for real estate covers that broader view.

Internal Rate of Return (IRR)

IRR calculates an annualized return that accounts for the timing of every cash flow in and out, including the sale. It is more complex, but it is the right tool for comparing deals with different hold periods or uneven cash flows.

A strong investment usually balances all three: solid current cash flow (cash on cash), healthy property-level income (cap rate) and long-term growth (total ROI).

Common Mistakes When Calculating Cash on Cash Return

A person using a calculator with documents spread on a table

Underestimating Operating Expenses

Taxes and insurance are easy to remember. The less visible costs are what usually get left out:

  • Vacancy: Many investors set aside 5 to 10% of gross rent for months between tenants.
  • Repairs and maintenance: Faucets leak and disposals jam. A common placeholder is another 5 to 10% of gross rent.
  • CapEx: Roofs, HVAC systems and water heaters wear out. Reserving around 5% of rent in a separate fund keeps a large replacement from wiping out a year of cash flow.

In Example 2 above, dropping the vacancy, maintenance and CapEx lines would raise cash flow to about $7,437 (management rises slightly, since it is then charged on the full rent) and push the return from 9.7% to 16.5%. That is how a mediocre deal starts to look like a great one on paper.

Forgetting Initial Costs

Count every dollar that left your account: down payment, closing costs, inspection and appraisal fees, and rent-ready repairs. In Example 2, using only the $35,000 down payment as the denominator would overstate the return as 12.5% instead of 9.7%.

Ignoring Red Flags

A very high projected return can hide real problems: a declining neighborhood, a failing foundation or rents that only hold up on paper. Balance the spreadsheet with on-the-ground due diligence. A dependable 10% on a sound property beats a projected 20% on one that needs a new foundation.

Frequently asked questions

What is a good cash on cash return for a rental property?

For a leveraged long-term rental, many investors use 8 to 12% as a working target and treat anything above 12% as strong. All-cash buyers and investors in high-appreciation markets often accept less. Treat the range as a screen, then judge the deal on its risk and your goals.

What's a good cash on cash return for an all-cash purchase?

All-cash returns usually land a little below the cap rate, because closing costs and repairs add to your cash invested. In the example above, a 9.1% cap rate produced an 8.5% all-cash return. Many all-cash buyers are comfortable with a lower number because there is no loan payment to cover.

Is a 5% cash on cash return good?

It can be, depending on the strategy. For a leveraged rental bought mainly for income, 5% is below the common screen. For an all-cash buyer in a strong appreciation market, or for a property with significant planned rent increases, 5% may be acceptable.

What is the difference between cash on cash return and ROI?

Cash on cash return measures the cash you receive each year against the cash you put in. ROI is broader: it includes cash flow plus appreciation and equity from loan paydown, usually measured over the full hold or at sale.

How can I increase my cash on cash return?

Raise income (competitive rent, small upgrades that justify higher rent), lower operating costs (shop insurance, appeal an inflated tax assessment) or reduce debt service by refinancing when rates fall. On a BRRRR deal, pulling more of your cash out at refinance also raises the percentage.

Is a lower cash on cash return ever a good thing?

Sometimes. In high-growth markets, some investors accept a low or near-zero return because they expect appreciation to make up the difference. That is a higher-risk approach, since it depends on future prices rather than current income.


Thinking about a flip instead of a hold? FlipSmrt pulls recent sold comps, prices the rehab line by line and gives you ARV, MAO and a go/no-go verdict in under 5 minutes. Analyze a property free (your first 3 analyses are free).

Found this helpful? Share it:

Ready to analyze your next property?

Get ARV from real sold comps, line-item renovation estimates and a go or no-go verdict in under 5 minutes. Your first 3 analyses are free.